Who Else Wants That Ulster County House This Winter?

In the third quarter of 2026, Ulster County's median sale price rose 7.5% from a year earlier to $500,000. Over the same three months, new listings rose 35.2% and pending sales fell 3.2%. Both numbers come from the same OneKey MLS quarterly report, and they describe different moments in time. The median price is drawn from deals that have already closed. The counts of new listings and pending contracts show what is coming onto the market and how much of it buyers are taking. In this market, the buyer's position depends on more than the county totals. It also depends on who already owns the houses in the town where you're shopping.

Listings are rising faster than pending sales

A closing is the last step in a sale, so the 288 closings OneKey recorded for Ulster in Q3 2026, up 13.8% from Q3 2025, count deals at the finish line. OneKey's pending sales count is a step earlier in the pipeline, and it moved the other way. In Q3 2026 there were 272 pending sales, compared with 281 in Q3 2025. In the same quarter, 492 new listings came on the market, up from 364.

When listings grow by a third and pending sales stay flat, unsold homes pile up. By the end of Q3 2026, Ulster had 529 homes for sale, up 27.2% from a year earlier. That's 6.7 months of supply, up from 5.4 in Q3 2025. Months of supply estimates how long the current stock would last if nothing new were listed and sales kept their recent pace. At 6.7 months, buyers can compare homes before deciding, not just react to them.

Speed hasn't collapsed. Homes in Q3 2026 averaged 55 days on market, down from 60 a year earlier. OneKey counts days on market from listing to an accepted offer, not to closing. So the homes that sold went under contract a bit faster than last year, while more homes sat waiting. Well-priced homes still move. Overpriced ones now have more company.

September is where the slack began to show in price

The monthly single-family report for September 2026, linked from the Hudson Gateway Association of Realtors market stats page, shows the same pattern more sharply. In September, 175 single-family homes came on the market, up 41.1% from September 2025, and single-family inventory reached 511 homes, up 24.6%.

That month, single-family sellers received 97.2% of their original list price on average, down from 100.5% in September 2025. Across all property types for the full quarter, the figure was 99.0%. The September single-family number is the later and narrower reading, and it's the one closest to the market a buyer will see on Thanksgiving weekend. The single-family median that month was $485,000, up only 3.2% from a year earlier, a smaller gain than the quarter's 7.5%.

The 97.2% figure measures the average gap between a home's first asking price and its final sale price. It doesn't count how many homes sold over asking. In practice, a seller who listed at $500,000 in September 2025 typically got that much or more. In September 2026, a seller at the same list price averaged closer to $486,000. That difference is the room a buyer has to negotiate this winter, on average across the county.

The averages blend towns with very different owners

County figures combine places as different as Uptown Kingston, a hamlet in Shandaken and a street near SUNY New Paltz. A November 2026 study from Hudson Valley Pattern for Progress, "Commercialization of Housing," shows how differently those places are owned.

Countywide, the picture is less alarming than "investor" headlines suggest. In 2025, about 2,400 of Ulster's roughly 53,100 one-to-four-family parcels were owned by corporate entities such as LLCs, or about 5%. Of those, 90% had in-state mailing addresses and 57% belonged to owners with ten or fewer parcels. The study found no substantial holdings by large national institutional investors in the region. Ulster had the study area's highest share of what Pattern calls likely small local landlords, owners of two to four properties whose mailing address is in the same ZIP code as the property, at nearly 13%.

Those owners are spread unevenly, though. In 2025, the Ulster towns with the most corporate-owned one-to-four-family homes were Saugerties with 263, or 4% of that housing; Wawarsing with 234, or 8%; New Paltz with 172, or 6%; Woodstock with 135, or 5%; and Shandaken with 117, or 7%. Pattern links these towns to tourism around the Catskills and the Shawangunks. The City of Kingston had 507, or 8%, and Pattern links it to a different pattern.

These are counts of who owns homes now, not who bought them this fall. Still, they show which kind of competing buyer has historically shown up in each town, and that affects how a looser market plays out there.

In the Catskill and Gunks towns, the other bidder is often pricing in rental income

Short-term rental listings on Airbnb in Ulster grew from just over 700 in 2015 to more than 2,300 in 2025, about 3% of the county's housing. Across the six-county study area, 21% to 32% of Airbnb listings name hosts based in New York City, and 35% to 48% belong to hosts with more than one listing. In Ulster and three other counties, corporate ownership grew by 19% to 33% after 2020, and Pattern attributes that to pandemic-era tourism and second-home demand.

Real estate agents interviewed for the study said many buyers in Ulster towns ask about local short-term rental rules to judge whether rental income could offset the cost of a second home. Stakeholders also said listings in many of these towns are marketed as second homes with rental potential.

This is why the town matters. Someone planning to live in a house sets a price from what they can afford each month, while a buyer planning to rent it out works from projected booking revenue. In Woodstock, Saugerties, Shandaken or New Paltz, both kinds of buyer are often after the same listing, and their maximum offers come from different math. When inventory grows as it did in Q3 2026, the buyer counting on rental income has to make an assumption about future bookings work across more competing homes. The owner-occupant's budget doesn't depend on that assumption. On a house that suits both, a buyer who knows their own monthly number can negotiate more steadily than one depending on occupancy projections.

Kingston's competing owner is a long-term landlord, and new supply is still on paper

Pattern groups Kingston with Newburgh, Poughkeepsie and Middletown. These are cities where mid-century disinvestment lowered property values and made room for investor purchases, and Kingston ranks highest of all Ulster municipalities by count of corporate-owned one-to-four-family homes. In Kingston, then, the other bidder on a two-family or a house in the Rondout is often a landlord working from long-term rents, a different calculation from the tourism-driven one in the mountain towns.

New housing that could change Kingston's supply is still mostly in the proposal stage. Kingston Wire reported in October 2026 on a proposed six-story, 135-unit affordable development at 111 Schwenk Drive with no construction timeline, next to the planned Kingstonian with 129 market-rate and 14 affordable units. In November, Hudson Valley One reported that the Common Council overrode a mayoral veto of a moratorium on selling city-owned parking lots, and the paper reported that the vote delays a proposed 50-unit affordable project at 65–77 North Front Street pending a citywide parking study expected in fall 2027. For a buyer, this means the Kingston homes available this winter are almost entirely existing houses, so the county's rising listing count applies to resale stock.

Turning the county numbers into a town-specific offer

The county figures set the general conditions. Supply is up about a quarter year over year, pending contracts are slightly down, and in September single-family sellers averaged a few points below their original asking price. How a seller reacts to an offer below asking still depends on the town and on who else might bid.

In the Catskill and Gunks towns, find out whether a listing is marketed for its rental potential and how long it has been on the market. A home priced on rental projections that hasn't gotten an accepted offer within the county's average of about two months is the kind of listing where the September numbers suggest room to negotiate. In Kingston, the comparison is closer to rental-property math. Comparable sales in the same neighborhood, and what a long-term landlord could pay for the same house, show where the seller's real floor is. Across the county, comparable sales should come from the specific town and the last few months, because a countywide median blends every town and every month of closings into one number.

Our Ulster County neighborhood guide covers the towns themselves. If a rental is part of your plan, our earlier post on turning an Ulster County home into a short-term rental is a useful companion, and the buyer's guide goes through the steps from search to closing.

At The Machree Group, we're glad to sit down with the recent sales in the town you're considering and talk through what this winter's market means for your offer. Let's connect and start your Hudson Valley project.

Work With Us

At The Machree Group, LLC, you will find a wide range of services from vacation rentals, vacation home purchases, how to buy land and build your dream house and much more!

CONTACT US